Mastro's Steakhouse - Chicago reviews


  • 5
  • 4
  • 3
  • 2
  • 1

Overall Rating

93% would recommend it to a friend
Noise Level


by Frenchie on July 20, 2018
A nice steakhouse to frequent often. Very nice restaurant with the perfect ambiance and delicious food especially the steak and corn...Martinis are great too.
by OpenTable Diner on July 20, 2018
Always outstanding! Live music a plus. Jeff is the best server
by MaryJ on July 20, 2018
good service, good food, fun evening with a great friend!
by RichP on July 18, 2018
I had the pleasure eating at Mastro's several times in Chicago and their other locations. I can tell you the food is outstanding. The seafood tower appetizer is truly amazing as our of course the steaks, side dishes and desert offerings. I have the opportunity to travel all over the country and have been to many steakhouses and Mastro's tops them all. No need to add any type of toppings to any of their steaks as the meat is tasty and tender by itself. This is truly a gem.
by StanH on July 17, 2018
Robbie was great. Food was very good. We sat next to a group of 12 very LOUD business guys. Still it was an overall good experience. I had the bone-in filet. I would highly recommend it.
by OpenTable Diner on July 16, 2018
My favorite steak house in Chicago. Everything is on point.
by Moll on July 16, 2018
Dinner was a little too long for my liking on a Monday night.
by Amykins on July 16, 2018
My cousin and I dined together to celebrate some recent success. We ate in the lounge instead of the dining room. The service was good, wine selection was great, the food was amazing and the live music entertainment sounded great. We will definitely be back.
by OpenTable Diner on July 14, 2018
I’ve been to Mastro‘s a few times, both in Chicago and in Scottsdale. I’ve always been impressed by the quality of the waitstaff and the outstanding food. This trip was just kind of average. That just about sums everything up. The food was average, the drinks were average, and the service was average. It was a reservation towards the end of the evening and from the get go, the waitress seemed to be a little edgy. She was almost Condescending at times. The comment that comes to mind is “usually I will pour the rest of your drink for you, if you’re going to do it yourself, just make sure you hold the top of the shaker so you don’t pour it all over yourself”. I guess she assumed I had never poured myself a drink before. I have no problem paying for an outstanding meal, but I’m not a big fan of spending $300 for two people when everything is average.
by OpenTable Diner on July 14, 2018
Food was delicious and great server as well! Gave great recommendations. Only negative thing to say was we both order cocktails and I’m pretty sure they were 100% vodka and everything else in the drink was forgotten. Not to complain about how strong they were but it would have been nice to have a little flavor as we were expecting. Other than that small disappointment we will definitely be returning again maybe just order wine next time!
by OpenTable Diner on July 14, 2018
Absolutely outstanding food and service! Highly recommend!
by tklos1974 on July 14, 2018
Been there a number of times and figured it was a no-brainer for 10 yr anniversary.
by gaf1 on July 14, 2018
everything was great other than the waiter and staff rushed us throughout the evening.
by travis on July 14, 2018
It was just ok. We have been to Mastro's in other cities, with better success. For the money, the steaks weren't on par with expectations and comparable locations in Chicago. It left us feeling a bit underwhelmed. And considering we talked it up with our group, disappointed.
by PattyO on July 14, 2018
Amazing service, thank you, Kyle!, and wonderful food, thank you Chef Matt Smith and your colleagues! We celebrated our mom's 75th birthday and our group of seven were all very happy. The kitchen is happy to slice meats so guests can taste different cuts and share with the table, along with the scrumptious sides. Warm Butter Cake. Mic. Drop.
by OpenTable Diner on July 13, 2018
Food was subpar compared to previous experiences. Long time customer, slightly disappointed. My dates lobster came out lukewarm, my steak was well done not medium. All this for a 400+ bill after tip. Strongly considering prime And provision next time.
by SW12 on July 12, 2018
I really enjoyed my time at Mastro's. The food was great. The live music was excellent. Also, the cocktails were on point. It is a bit pricey so this is not the place you want to go if you are on a budget. However, it is well worth it. I will definitely be returning.
by Dennis on July 10, 2018
Best ny strip steak in memory. First time in Chicago and wanted that Chicago Steak house experience. They did not disapoint.
by NancyA on July 7, 2018
If I could give more stars I would. The food was amazing and the service was outstanding. Our server was very helpful and knowledgeable with the menu items and gave us the best recommendations. Will definitely return.
by OpenTable Diner on July 7, 2018
My boneless ribeye was completely inedible because of the gristle. Certainly not what you would expect from a steakhouse of this caliber. The Alaskan crab gnocchi were almost disgustingly rich. You really couldn’t eat more than a bite or two. When the waitress asked why I hadn’t eaten much of my steak I let her know and they delivered a butter cake dessert (that we had not requested) and apologized for the poor quality steak and advised we would not be charged. We accepted their apology but when the bill came although we were not charged for the terrible and inedible steak, we discovered they had charged us for the “complimentary” dessert! Terrible experience! Take my advice, go to one of the multitude of other steakhouses that will deliver a higher quality meal !
by OpenTable Diner on July 7, 2018
Wonderful evening- food, drinks, service and ambience were all terrific! Will definitely return on our next trip to Chicago!
by MarianneF on July 7, 2018
Our server, Jeff was exceptional. Gary the bartender was also superb. The cocktails were great- especially the Cosmo!~ Cherry Valley Pinot Noir was a great find!~
by JohnT on July 6, 2018
Didn’t feel like the food was worth the price. I have had superior meals at RPM and Gibson’s. Had to ask three times for a bread basket. It came after the appetizer arrived. Waiter was nice but I’m thinking the kitchen was the issue
by LawrenceH on July 6, 2018
The staff who checked us in were rude.
by OpenTable Diner on July 6, 2018
Amazing always
by marcm on July 1, 2018
My steak wasn't as good compared to Gisbon Steak House which I visited the day before however i did enjoy my sides which included a double baked potato and creamed spinach
by AADiner on July 1, 2018
A truly exceptional meal from start to finish. Can’t wait to return on our next trip to Chicago.
by JohnLF on July 1, 2018
Truly impressive and an overall great dinner! Never left the bar area which is the perfect spot for love music and great service. Thank you!
by OpenTable Diner on July 1, 2018
I love the steak taste and oh my god : the portion is so big, lol. And the have really nice live music going on. I would love to come back again
by OpenTable Diner on June 30, 2018
You won't be disappointed
by KeithA on June 30, 2018
The food was top notch and the service was excellent. Our server was more than helpful and very attentive.
by SteveA on June 30, 2018
This is a fine steakhouse. Ronnie, who assists with our wine selection, is friendly and knowledgable. One of our favorite places to eat. And, the warm butter cake is like a twinkie on steroids.......
by OpenTable Diner on June 30, 2018
Great server! Friendly and respectful. Food was outstanding!
by RoxAnnM on June 28, 2018
We love Maetsro's. Been here many times. Consistent high quality steaks. Nice wine list. Recommend sitting in the bar and enjoy the music.
by OpenTable Diner on June 24, 2018
Great service, food and piano/singing!
by DivyaG on June 23, 2018
Best rack of lamb and butter cake I have ever had :)
by OpenTable Diner on June 23, 2018
Wife and I always look for a nice place to dress up and grab a great steak. This place was awesome!
by ARob on June 23, 2018
Food was fantastic, service was very good. Seafood tower was awesome. Lobster bisque was the best we've ever tasted. Crab cakes were perfect. Actually, every bite was perfect. The butter cake... unbelievable!
by veganstylist on June 23, 2018
Then meal is overpriced. The food is great and the service was exceptional. It was a great evening but I do believe your prices could be a lot less.
by Dennis1 on June 23, 2018
Everything was outstanding! Hopefully, management decides to one day open a Toronto location.
by MRChicago on June 23, 2018
steaks were overdone and served lukewarm. Expected much more given prices. Salad was almost tasteless. Pecan pie was excellent!
by Snoopy on June 22, 2018
Great food and service. We sat in the bar to be near the music and the live entertainment was spectacular. Can't wait to go back. Thanks.
by OpenTable Diner on June 22, 2018
Great!!! Enjoyed by all
by KarenB on June 22, 2018
Absolutely fantastic meal! There were four of us, our servers name was Justin, and nothing could have been better. Best steak I’ve ever had!
by geoffreym on June 21, 2018
We came in and and celebrated a Graduation + Bday Everything was excellent Very different energy here compared to the Las Vegas one The quality of food and service both ! Hope they open Honolulu soon!
by OpenTable Diner on June 21, 2018
Wife’s birthday
by EmilyK on June 21, 2018
This food and this restaurant was top notch. My husband and I went before the theater and it was perfect. We paid quite a bit for our dinner but it was worth every penny. We have already recommended this place to a friend. The butter cake is the best dessert I have every eaten! And our server, June, was wonderful!
by OpenTable Diner on June 20, 2018
We had an amazing 3rd anniversary! Special thanks to the Mastro’s staff for making the evening amazing :)
by Mountainbikemom on June 18, 2018
Kyle was a fantastic server. Food was excellent. Just wish they would enforce the strict dress they state. Men in basketball shorts , T-shirt’s and slides. Also kids running around dining room. The live music entertainment was awesome!!!
by OpenTable Diner on June 17, 2018
Lobster was not fresh and over cooked the meat was tough
Find a Table